Software Development

Overusing the Null-Conditional Operator

The null-conditional operator is the ?. between object and field/property/method. It simply says that if the thing on the left hand side is null then the thing on the right hand side is not evaluated. It is a shorthand, so:

if (a != null)



And that’s great. It makes life much simpler, and if you’re using ReSharper it will alert you when you could use this operator over a null guard check.

But, and this is quite a big “but”, I have noticed a trend to overuse it.

I’ve seen people do crazy stuff like replace most (almost all) instances of the dot-operator so their code is littered with these question-marks before the dot.

var result = myObject?.GetSomething()?.SomeValue?.ToString()?.Split()?.Where(s=>s?.Length > 0);

And when you get to that level of lunacy you’re basically turning on the old Visual Basic OnError Resume Next head-in-the-sand error handling anti-pattern.

I want to make this absolutely clear. The null-conditional operator is not bad, per se. However, over using it or using it without thought to the logic of your application is bad as it hides potential bugs.

You should only use it when you would normally do a null check in advance. If ReSharper says you can refactor your code to use it, then it most likely is fine to use (you were probably using a longer construct for the same thing already which implies you’ve most likely thought about it – No on likes writing reams of code for no good reason).

Software Development

Application Configuration in .NET Core – Part 2

In the first part we got started by pulling in configuration data from multiple source in .NET Core, in this part we’ll look at mapping the configuration onto a set of classes so that is becomes easier to access.

This is something that is built into ASP.NET Core through dependency injection, so we’ll look at that.

In ASP.NET Core applications, the configuration is setup in the Startup class normally. It is added in the ConfigureServices method. There are two lines you need to add:

public void ConfigureServices(IServiceCollection services)
  // Other services are configured here.

In order to get them to compile you need an additional NuGet package called Microsoft.Extensions.Options.ConfigurationExtensions. This ensures that everything you need to have configuration converted to the type you specify is set up and that it can be dependency injected into your code.

The GetConfiguration() call is to get the generated IConfigurationRoot and looks similar to the way we set up the configuration int the previous post. For this example it looks like this:

private IConfigurationRoot GetConfiguration()
  var builder = new ConfigurationBuilder();

  builder.AddInMemoryCollection(new Dictionary<string, string>
    { "InMemory", "This value comes from the in-memory collection" }


  return builder.Build();

I’ve added configuration from the environment variables as well.

As the app is configured to map the configuration settings to an object structure, here’s what it looks like:

public class MyConfiguration
  public string UserName { get; set; } // From the environment variable of the same name
  public string InMemory { get; set; } // From the in-memory collection
  public string RootItem { get; set; } // from appSettings.json
  public FavouriteStuff Favourites { get; set; } // from appSettings.json
  public string[] Fruits { get; set; } // from appSettings.json

public class FavouriteStuff
  public string TvShow { get; set; }
  public string Movie { get; set; }
  public string Food { get; set; }
  public string Drink { get; set; }

As you can see the structure can be deep if necessary which gives you quite a lot of flexibility.

The appSettings.json file looks like this:

  "RootItem": "This is at the root",
  "Favourites": {
    "TvShow": "Star Trek: The Next Generation",
    "Movie": "First Contact",
    "Food": "Haggis",
    "Drink":  "Cream Soda"  
  "Fruits": [

Now, the controller that needs the configuration information looks like this:

public class HomeController : Controller
    private readonly IOptions<MyConfiguration> _config;

    public HomeController(IOptions<MyConfiguration> config)
        _config = config;
    public IActionResult Index()
        JsonSerializerSettings settings = new JsonSerializerSettings();
        settings.Formatting = Formatting.Indented;
        return new JsonResult(_config.Value, settings);

All this does is take the `MyConfiguration` object created by the framework on our behalf and render it as JSON to the browser. The key parts are that the constructor takes an IOptions<MyConfiguration> reference, which you store in the controller and you can then access as needed in any of the methods of the controller.

Finally, the output in the browser looks as follows.

  "UserName": "colin.mackay",
  "InMemory": "This value comes from the in-memory collection",
  "RootItem": "This is at the root",
  "Favourites": {
    "TvShow": "Star Trek: The Next Generation",
    "Movie": "First Contact",
    "Food": "Haggis",
    "Drink": "Cream Soda"
  "Fruits": [

It looks very similar to the appSettings.json file, but you can see that it has, in addition, the “UserName” and “InMemory” elements which don’t appear in that file.

Software Development

Application configuration in .NET Core – Part 1

.NET Core has a new way of working with configuration that is much more flexible than the way that previous versions of .NET have.

It allows you to:

  1. Pull configuration from multiple sources and bring it in to one place.
  2. Easily map that configuration information into classes to make access easier.
  3. Override configuration from previous sources so that you can import a base configuration then override settings on per-environment basis.

This post will be concerned with the first of these: Pulling configuration from multiple sources and bringing it together in to one place. We’ll discuss the second and third aspect in future posts.

Getting Started

To use it you need to add the Microsoft.Extensions.Configuration NuGet package to your application.

Microsoft.Extensions.Configuration 1.0.0 NuGet package
Microsoft.Extensions.Configuration NuGet package

Once you’ve imported the package your project.json will contain:

  "dependencies": {
    "Microsoft.Extensions.Configuration": "1.0.0",
    .... Other dependencies here ....

From the basic configuration package you don’t really get much in the way of configuration sources, only the in-memory one is available. However, that’s just enough to show you the basic set up of the configuration in an application.

public class Program
    public static void Main(string[] args)
        // Defines the sources of configuration information for the 
        // application.
        var builder = new ConfigurationBuilder()
            .AddInMemoryCollection(new []
                new KeyValuePair<string, string>("the-key", "the-value"),

        // Create the configuration object that the application will
        // use to retrieve configuration information.
        var configuration = builder.Build();

        // Retrieve the configuration information.
        var configValue = configuration["the-key"];
        Console.WriteLine($"The value for 'the-key' is '{configValue}'");


The builder is the thing that allows you to set up the sources of configuration information. Each provider adds extension methods so you can add them easily to the builder. The InMemoryCollection simply takes an IEnumerable of KeyValuePairs to initialise its values.

Once you have set up your configuration sources you can build all that into an actual object you can use in your application, by calling Build() on the builder object. From here on you can access configuration values with indexer notation.

Adding a JSON File Source

So far, what we have isn’t very useful. We need to pull configuration information from outside the application such as a JSON file. To do that, we need to add another NuGet package. This one provides a JSON provider and is called Microsoft.Extensions.Configuration.Json.

Microsoft.Extensions.Configuration.Json NuGet package
Microsoft.Extensions.Configuration.Json NuGet package

We can now extend the simple application above by adding an appsettings.json file and adding in the code to build it.

var builder = new ConfigurationBuilder()
    .AddInMemoryCollection(new []
        new KeyValuePair("the-key", "the-value"),

And the appsettings.json looks like this:

  "my-other-key": "my-other-value" 

And the value is retrieved like any other:

configValue = configuration["my-other-key"];
Console.WriteLine($"The value for 'my-other-key' is '{configValue}'");

However, while this looks like it should work, it won’t. When you added a settings file previously, Visual Studio would mark it for copying to the output folder so that the running application could find it. However, it doesn’t do that with .NET Core (yet – I do hope they add it).

Instead you get a FileNotFoundException, like this:

Exception Assistant showing a File Not Found Exception
An unhandled exception of type ‘System.IO.FileNotFoundException’ occurred in Microsoft.Extensions.Configuration.FileExtensions.dll Additional information: The configuration file ‘appsettings.json’ was not found and is not optional.

To get the appsettings.json file added to the output folder you are going to have to modify the project.json file.

In the buildOptions section add copyToOutput with the name of the file. If there is more than one file you can put in an array of files rather than just the one. The top of the project.json file now looks like this:

  "version": "1.0.0-*",
  "buildOptions": {
    "emitEntryPoint": true,
    "copyToOutput": "appsettings.json"
  .... The rest of the file goes here ....

The next time the project is run it will copy the appsettings.json file and you won’t get an exception to say that the file was not found.


DDD Scotland final agenda

ddds-unicorn-side-284-086We’ve finalised our agenda and already people have said they’re finding it difficult to decide which sessions to see and which they’ll have to miss out on.

For full information visit Tickets are available here.

Napier / Doyle Lauder / Heriot Clark Greyfriar
08:30 Registration
09:20 Welcome and housekeeping
09:30 Paul Gillespie
Architecture at Web scale: the good, the bad and the ugly
Keith Kirkhope
A Squad Lead’s tale: the Skyscanner Squads model
Christos Matskas
ASP.NET Core (formerly 5) deep dive
Matt Lacey
Six dimensional mobile user experiences
10:30 Break
10:50 Craig Nicol
Developers are users too : why the user experience of your API sucks
Clarke Ching
Lesstimating: how to fix estimating by doing less of it, not none of it.
Naeem Sarfraz
Windows brings Docker Goodness – What does it mean for .NET developers?
Chris Canal
React for the .Net Developer
11:50 Break
12:10 Raymond Davies
Breaking the monolith
Nathan Gloyn
You keep using the word agile, I do not think it means what you think it means
Gary Ewan Park
Having your Cake, and eating to too!
Don Wibier
Responsive Web Design for Developers
13:10 Lunch
14:25 Sebastien Lambla
Versions are evil – How to do without in your APIs
Chris McDermott
“Ladies and gentlemen, the plane is no longer the problem”
Toby Henderson
Brighter to the Core, moving an OSS project to .Net Core 1.0
Gary Short
Would You Have Survived The Titanic?
15:25 Break
15:45 Max Vasilyev
CQRS and how it can make your architecture better
Richard Dalton & Ashic Mahtab
“Advanced” Functional Programming For The Absolute Beginner
Mike Ritchie
The Code Craftsmanship Thing for the Internet Of Things Thing
Kendall Miller
To The Cloud! How Azure helped us improve the scalability of our SaaS
16:45 Prize draw
17:15 Close


Software Development

Setting up Ubuntu for .NET Development

First up, at the time of writing only Ubuntu 14.04LTS is supported. I’ve read that it will work on 15.04, but I know it won’t work on 15.10 because of a binary incompatibility on a library that .net core relies on.

Step 1: Install the .NET Execution Environment

Follow the instructions at

This will install the .NET Execution Environment (DNX)

Step 2: Install Node.js

Since .NET Core relies on node js for parts, and there are some cool code generators using node.js as the templating engine, install node.js by following the instructions here:

I used version 4.x LTS (4.4.1 to be exact)

Step 3: Install Visual Studio Code

This is actually optional – I’m installing it because I wanted to get the standard IDE for C#. You can get away with running just the regular text editor installed with Ubuntu.

First, download Visual Studio Code. Then follow the setup instructions…. Kind of.

Unzipped the zip file to /usr/local/bin with

sudo unzip ~/Downloads/

Then I created the link as in the instructions so that I can launch from the terminal.

To launch from the terminal and get the prompt back use

code &

Step 4: Install Yeoman

Before you do, you’ll need up to update NPM as the version that comes with 4.x LTS is older and the current version of Yeomen doesn’t like it.

sudo npm install -g npm

Install yoman by following the instructions here:

Remember to put sudo in front of install commands specifying -g (global) otherwise you’ll get an error message.

Step 5: Create a project

Move to a directory that you want to create a new project in. I use ~/dev for all my development work.

Then start Yeoman with:

yo aspnet

This will result in a prompt that looks like this:

    |       |    .--------------------------.
    |--(o)--|    |      Welcome to the      |
   `---------´   |   marvellous ASP.NET 5   |
    ( _´U`_ )    |        generator!        |
    /___A___\    '--------------------------'
     |  ~  |     
 ´   `  |° ´ Y ` 

? What type of application do you want to create? (Use arrow keys)
❯ Empty Application 
  Console Application 
  Web Application 
  Web Application Basic [without Membership and Authorization] 
  Web API Application 
  Nancy ASP.NET Application 
  Class Library 
  Unit test project 

You can then use the arrow keys to move up and down the list.

Choose “Web Application Basic”

It will then prompt for a name. I chose “MyHelloWorldApp”

It will create that directory and populate it with files for the project. You’ll still need to restore the packages that you need, and yeomen gives you some help on getting that done.

If you follow the yeomen instructions you’ll find that at the dnu build step it fails. This is because the project template has dual targeting. It targets .NET 4.5.1 and .NET Core. On Linux only .NET Core will run. To remove the dual targetting open the project.json file and find the section that looks like this:

  "frameworks": {
    "dnx451": {},
    "dnxcore50": {}

And remove the entry for "dnx451" then save the file.

dnu build won’t work just yet. If you try it you’ll get an error message:

/home/colin/dev/MyHelloWorldApp/project.lock.json(1,0): error NU1006: Dependencies in project.json were modified. Please run "dnu restore" to generate a new lock file.

Build failed.
    0 Warning(s)
    1 Error(s)

So, run dnu restore once again so that the dependencies synchronised with the project.

Once that’s done type dnu build and it will now succeed.

You now have a basic environment set up on Linux for developing .NET Core applications and have demonstrated that you can create and build a simple ASP.NET Core application.

Tip of the Day

Tip of the Day: Calculating durations with Moment

Moment has quite a nice fluent interface for some operations, others just need a little more thought.

For example, I wanted the duration of something and I had recorded the start and end time. I thought something like this, finding the difference between two dates and converting it to a duration, would work:

var duration = endTime.diff(startTime).duration().asSeconds();

However, that doesn’t work.

What you have to do is find the difference, then pass that into the duration function, like this:

var duration = moment.duration(endTime.diff(startTime)).asSeconds();

And now I get what I wanted.

In the workplace

Estimates are not deadlines

This is another one of those cautionary tales of what not to do.

A number of years ago I worked for a digital agency. For most of my time there I worked on systems in a specific market sector and I got to know it quite well. Then a brief came in from a new client in that sector who wanted a new website. It seemed natural that I was asked to work on that project.

It was also natural that we should work out if the brief was doable within the budget that the client had, so we got to work analysing the requirements and estimating how long it would take. This was then translated into billable hours and compared against the client’s budget.

The estimate showed that the work could not be completed within the client’s budget.

At some point shortly after that word from on high was that we needed to make it work within budget, and the development manager then asked us where we could make savings. He went through with us all the estimates attempting to find out if we’d padded them out.

Although we managed to cut the estimates down a little they were still too high. We needed more cuts. We needed to cut 22.8% from the estimates.

At the time, we were using the project to trial a new project management tool called VersionOne so all the tasks and estimates were in that system. Some things were estimated at an hour, some two hours, some four hours, some a day. All rounded numbers. All based on a gut feel in the very early stages of a project when we still didn’t know half the information we really needed, which is to say these estimated weren’t even educated guesses, some numbers were picked from the air, some were based on experience in other projects which were similar but not the same.

The estimate we came up with for the project was our best guess with the information we had.

Then a day or two after the exercise to pare back the initial estimates I came in to discover that all the estimates, every single last one of them, had been revised downwards. I may not have immediately noticed if it wasn’t for the fact that they no longer had nice rounded numbers.

For example, all the tasks that was estimated originally for 2 hours were now estimated as 1 hour, 37 minutes, and 42 seconds. Gosh! That’s an awfully precise estimate. I can hardly call it an accurate estimate.

The Development Manager, in order to meet the board’s approval, had cut precisely the amount needed to meet the budget on every single task. The project now came in almost exactly on budget.

When the work actually started it was clear that the estimates were wildly out in some cases. Not just the overly precise revised estimated, but the original estimates too.

The company culture being what it was, stress was applied to ensure that work was proceeding on scheudle. Developers were held to the estimates, even although they weren’t the original estimates, and estimates are just guesses based on the information available at the time.

There are a number of solutions to this, however, the company was not receptive to those ideas. Their model was the client says jump, they respond how high. Then they whip their staff until the desired height is reached.